Who Will Make the Giants 53-Man Roster Among Berrios Beckham and Smith-Schuster
- Barry Jordan
- Jun 12
- 3 min read
The New York Giants have taken a cautious approach to their wide receiver room heading into the 2026 season. With Malik Nabers still recovering from a complicated ACL injury suffered in Week 4 of 2025, the team signed three veteran receivers, Braxton Berrios, Odell Beckham Jr., and JuJu Smith-Schuster, on one-year, team-friendly deals. These signings reflect the uncertainty around Nabers’ availability and the need for depth, but none of these veterans have a guaranteed spot on the final 53-man roster. This post breaks down each player’s chances and what factors will decide who makes the cut.
Braxton Berrios and His Return Specialist Role
Braxton Berrios joined the Giants after Gunner Olszewski tore his Achilles in OTAs, creating an immediate need for a return specialist. Berrios’ primary value lies in his ability to handle punt and kickoff returns, a role that can secure a roster spot if executed well. However, the Giants have other players like Calvin Austin III competing for the same job, which puts Berrios on the roster bubble.
Berrios has shown flashes of playmaking ability in the return game during his career, but his offensive contributions as a receiver have been limited. The Giants will likely evaluate him heavily on special teams performance during training camp. If he cannot clearly outshine Austin or others in the return role, his chances of making the team diminish.
Odell Beckham Jr.’s Comeback Challenge
Odell Beckham Jr. returned to the Giants on a $1.3 million contract with no signing bonus, meaning he must make the team to earn his salary. OBJ’s star power and past production are undeniable, but he did not play at all during the 2025 season. This raises questions about his current form and ability to compete for targets in a crowded receiver room.
So far, OBJ looks good in camp, showing flashes of his old self. The Giants and fans alike have a sentimental attachment to him, which could influence decisions. Still, Beckham faces stiff competition from younger, healthier receivers. He must prove he can stay on the field and contribute consistently to justify a roster spot.
JuJu Smith-Schuster’s Practical Veteran Presence
JuJu Smith-Schuster signed as an unrestricted free agent and brings a practical, reliable veteran presence to the Giants. Compared to OBJ, JuJu is younger and has played more recently, which gives him an edge in terms of readiness and durability.
JuJu’s experience and versatility make him a strong candidate for the 53-man roster. He can contribute both as a receiver and on special teams, which adds value. The Giants will watch closely how he performs in training camp and preseason games, but his recent playing time and consistent production make him a likely choice.
The Crowded Receiver Room and What It Means
The Giants’ wide receiver room has been completely revamped, with a mix of veterans and younger players competing for limited spots. The final depth chart will depend heavily on training camp performance and the health of starters returning from injury.
Malik Nabers’ uncertain recovery means the Giants need reliable options ready to step in.
Competition is fierce with multiple receivers vying for snaps and special teams roles.
Coaches will prioritize versatility and availability, favoring players who can contribute in multiple ways.
This environment creates a challenging situation for Berrios, Beckham, and Smith-Schuster. None can rest on reputation alone; each must prove their value on the field.
Who Has the Edge?
JuJu Smith-Schuster appears to have the strongest case due to his recent playing experience and versatility.
Odell Beckham Jr. benefits from his star power and promising camp performance but must overcome doubts about his health and consistency.
Braxton Berrios faces the toughest battle, relying mainly on special teams to secure a spot amid strong competition.
The Giants’ coaching staff will watch closely during preseason games to see who can make the most impact. The crowded receiver room means some veterans may be cut despite their experience.
What Fans Should Watch For
How well each player performs in special teams drills and preseason games.
The pace of Malik Nabers’ recovery and whether he can return early in the season.
The chemistry each receiver builds with the Giants’ quarterbacks during camp.
Show your Giants Fandom and Get Your Giants Gear at NFL Shop Today!
Comments