Oregon Tops Our Preseason College Football Power Rankings in Big Ten Title Showdown
I didn’t ease into the first episode of “The 5.” I'm coming right out with a preseason power ranking that puts Oregon at No. 1, Ohio State at No. 2, and a potential Big Ten Championship Game collision in Indianapolis sitting right in the middle of the season’s biggest storyline.
That’s the point of the series. “The 5,” hosted on The Executive’s View throughout the college football season, isn’t built like a standard poll recap. I frames the list around his own metrics, roster reads, quarterback trust, coaching confidence, transfer impact, and the kind of gut-check questions that decide seasons once the games stop being theoretical.
My debut ranking makes one thing clear: talent matters, but quarterback trust is the separator.
Here’s how my preseason top five stacks up heading into the fall.
Rank | Team | Steve’s core reason |
No. 1 | Oregon Ducks | Dante Moore gives me the most quarterback confidence |
No. 2 | Ohio State Buckeyes | The roster may be the best in the country |
No. 3 | Georgia Bulldogs | Elite depth, but backup quarterback questions linger |
No. 4 | Texas Longhorns | Arch Manning plus portal firepower raises the standard |
No. 5 | Indiana Hoosiers | Defending title mentality keeps them dangerous |
Oregon claims No. 1 because Steve trusts Dante Moore
The top spot comes down to one thing I value more than almost anything else in a preseason projection: trust at quarterback.
Oregon edges Ohio State because I believe in Dante Moore more than any other signal-caller in his top five. That doesn’t mean Oregon has no questions. Every contender has them in August. But Steve’s read is that Moore gives the Ducks the clearest path to steady, high-level quarterback play.
That matters because Oregon’s ceiling is already high everywhere else.
I can point to the Ducks’ aggressive NIL investment, strong recruiting base, and the lessons learned from injury-affected stretches the previous season. In his view, Oregon has built the kind of roster that can absorb pressure and still win at the line of scrimmage, on the perimeter, and late in games.
The logic is simple. If the roster is deep, the talent is real, and the quarterback is the one I trust most, Oregon becomes the safest pick to sit at No. 1.
This is also where the ranking gets interesting. I'm not saying Oregon has dramatically more talent than Ohio State. In fact, I give Ohio State a huge amount of respect on that front. I'm saying that when two teams are close, the quarterback position becomes the deciding factor.
That’s a fair way to judge a preseason contender. Quarterback play changes everything: third downs, red-zone trips, two-minute drives, and the ability to survive a bad quarter without letting the game turn sideways.
Moore is the field general he’s most comfortable betting on.
Ohio State has the roster Steve may like most
Ohio State lands at No. 2, but my explanation almost sounds like a No. 1 argument.
The Buckeyes are arguably one of the most talented, complete teams in the sport and the most complete team in the country. The reason they don’t sit at the top is narrow but important: quarterback trust.
That’s not the same as saying Ohio State has a bad quarterback situation. Julian Sayin is one of the players that can define the Buckeyes’ season, and Jeremiah Smith in the category of players who can change the shape of a game with one snap.
Smith’s presence alone gives Ohio State a built-in weekly problem for defenses. A receiver with that kind of gravity affects coverage before the ball is even snapped. Safeties cheat. Corners play with less freedom. Defensive coordinators have to decide whether they’re willing to live with single coverage.
That opens space for everyone else.
My Ohio State ranking is built on the idea that personnel wins a lot of Saturdays. When the Buckeyes walk into most games, they’ll have more blue-chip ability than the team across from them. That usually travels well, especially over a long regular season.
Still, I hold them behind Oregon because he wants to see the quarterback position settle. If it does, his ranking already hints at the bigger takeaway: Ohio State could be his national championship pick even from the No. 2 slot.
That may sound odd at first, but it actually makes sense. A preseason ranking is a snapshot of confidence today. A title pick can include where I believe the team will be by December and January.
Right now, Oregon gets the trust edge. By the postseason, Ohio State may be the team Steve thinks has grown into the best version of itself.
Georgia remains dangerous, but the backup quarterback question is real
Georgia at No. 3 feels like the classic “yes, but” ranking.
Yes, I see Georgia as one of the most gifted rosters in the country. Yes, the Bulldogs have the depth, size, speed, and physical profile to line up against anybody. Yes, their personnel takes a back seat to no one.
But there is a specific concern: what happens if Gunner Stockton gets hurt?
That’s not a throwaway question. It’s one of the most uncomfortable parts of evaluating a title contender. Coaches can say all the right things about the quarterback room, but the reality is different when a backup has to enter a road game, a conference championship, or a playoff-level matchup with the season hanging in the balance.
One of the main concerns is about contingency planning.
If Stockton is healthy and effective, Georgia’s ranking could look conservative. The Bulldogs have enough across the roster to bully teams, win ugly, and still flash big-play ability. They can survive games where the offense isn’t perfect because the talent baseline is so high.
The worry comes if Georgia has to turn to either an unproven freshman or a veteran backup in high-pressure snaps. That’s not a small variable. A young quarterback may have the arm and confidence, but not the live-game processing. A veteran may have experience, but not the ceiling. Either path brings trade-offs.
Georgia’s spot at No. 3 shows how heavily we should weigh quarterback stability. We are not punishing the Bulldogs for lacking talent. But their season could swing on an injury scenario that other elite teams may be better built to manage.
That’s the difference between “loaded” and “fully trusted.”
Texas sits at No. 4 with a playoffs-or-bust standard
Ok so I make my Texas section personal. Everyone knows I call the Longhorns my team, then sets the bar exactly where a serious Texas season demands it: playoffs or bust.
That’s not soft preseason hype. That’s a standard.
The center of the conversation is Arch Manning. I can point to Manning’s late-season composure and growth, especially after the early media frenzy settled down. That’s an important distinction. Playing quarterback at Texas already brings pressure. Playing quarterback at Texas with the Manning name adds another layer.
Manning looked more comfortable once the noise faded and the football took over. That matters because talent has never been the question. The question is rhythm, command, decision-making, and whether he can lead a team with top-end expectations every week.
The portal additions are why Texas has the firepower to make the standard realistic.
Hollywood Smothers, coming from Louisville, gives the offense a backfield weapon who can add burst and versatility. Cam Coleman, coming from Auburn, adds another dangerous target on the outside. Together, they give Manning more ways to attack defenses and fewer excuses if the offense stalls.
What I like here is the combination of quarterback growth and skill-position upgrades. That’s usually how good offenses become great ones. The quarterback gets more comfortable, the system gives him answers, and the surrounding talent turns routine throws into chunk plays.
Texas at No. 4 is both respect and challenge. I believe the Longhorns belong in the national picture, but be clear that “pretty good” won’t be enough.
If Texas has the quarterback, the portal pieces, and the brand-level expectations, then the finish has to match.
Indiana gets respect as the defending champion
Indiana at No. 5 may be the most emotionally charged part of all my rankings.
I'm putting respect on the defending champions, and also tapping into one of the oldest motivators in sports: doubt.
The question around Indiana is obvious. Can they do it again?
I think that question will fuel the Hoosiers under head coach Curt Cignetti. A title team that still hears skepticism has an easy rallying point. Every offseason segment, every ranking that leaves them too low, every “prove it again” comment can become part of the message inside the building.
Cignetti’s presence matters here. I trust the scheme and the general roster foundation. That’s why Indiana makes the top five in the first place. Be clear, I'm not ranking them on nostalgia. I see enough structure and talent to believe the Hoosiers can remain in the fight.
But he also names the risk clearly: ball security from TCU transfer quarterback Josh Hoover.
That’s the kind of issue that can ruin a repeat bid fast. Turnovers don’t just end drives. They flip field position, wear down defenses, and give underdogs life. For a defending champion, giveaways also invite every opponent to believe the upset is sitting right there.
My concern isn’t that Hoover lacks ability. It’s that Indiana can’t afford careless possessions if the goal is to repeat. When a team has a target on its back, the margin often shrinks. Opponents prepare harder. Stadiums get louder. A normal mistake becomes a momentum swing.
Indiana’s ranking is a compliment with a warning attached because I believe the Hoosiers belong. I also believe their path depends on protecting the football like a veteran title team should.
The Big Ten title path runs through Oregon and Ohio State
The cleanest storyline from my first “The 5” entry is the projected Oregon and Ohio State collision.
I see the top two teams controlling their schedules and meeting in Indianapolis for the Big Ten Championship Game. That matchup would carry everything a conference title game should have: elite rosters, quarterback pressure, postseason stakes, and a possible national championship preview.
It also fits the way I built the ranking.
Oregon is No. 1 because of quarterback trust. Ohio State is No. 2 because of roster strength. Put those teams on the same field, and the game becomes a direct test of his preseason logic.
Can Dante Moore validate my confidence against one of the most talented defenses and overall rosters in the country?
Can Ohio State’s skill, depth, and explosiveness overwhelm the one category that kept the Buckeyes out of the top spot?
That’s what makes the projected matchup so strong. It isn’t just No. 1 versus No. 2. It’s one team built around my trust in the field general against another team that may have the best collection of talent in the sport.
The Big Ten Championship Game in Indianapolis would also shape the playoff conversation. A close game could keep both teams alive in the national race. A dominant win could reset the entire hierarchy before the postseason.
Ohio State remains the pick to win the national championship, even while Oregon opens at No. 1. That tension gives the series a built-in thread to follow all season.
The first ranking in college football is really about trust
The debut episode of “The 5” works because the ranking isn’t random. I have a theme, even if he doesn’t reduce it to one word.
That theme is trust.
I trust Oregon’s quarterback the most. I trust Ohio State’s roster more than almost anyone’s. I trust Georgia’s talent, but not the backup quarterback situation. I trust Texas’ ceiling, but demands a playoff finish. I also trust Indiana’s championship edge, as long as the ball-security issues don’t undo it.
That gives the top five a clear shape.
The list isn’t just about who has the most stars or the loudest preseason buzz. It’s about which teams I believe can handle the parts of a season that don’t show up cleanly on a depth chart: injuries, pressure, expectations, turnovers, and quarterback decisions in tight games.
That’s also why Oregon over Ohio State isn’t a wild swing. It’s a narrow preference based on the position that usually decides the biggest games.
If you’re getting ready for the season and want to rep your team before the first major Saturday, check out the latest gear here: shop college football fan gear.
My first top five gives the season a clean starting point. Oregon owns the top spot for now, Ohio State is close enough to take it, and Indianapolis already feels like the place where this argument could get settled.
Watch "The 5" on The Executive's View YouTube channel!
Comments