Did Peacock's NFL Playoff Gamble Pay Off?

Photo Credit: Ad Age

For the first time ever, a NFL playoff game was not aired on broadcasting television in favor of being aired exclusively on a streaming service. NBCUniversal’s Peacock streaming platform held the exclusive rights to the Saturday night matchup between the Miami Dolphins and the Kansas City Chiefs. While many complained about the switch in service, one can't deny the immediate impact the playoff gamble had for NBC.

Back in May of 2023, NBC paid $110 million for the exclusive rights to an NFL wild card playoff game to be streamed exclusively on their streaming service. Peacock’s Gamble landed them a juicy Chiefs vs Dolphins matchup on Saturday night filled with storylines. The Chiefs were victorious against the Dolphins 26-7. However, headlines added to the playoffs matchup as temperatures were well below freezing at -30 degrees, Tyreek Hill returned to the team that traded him away at his request and pop star Taylor Swift was in the house to watch her boyfriend Travis Kelsey. NBC couldn't script more headlines and buzz for their Peacock exclusive.

Photo Credit: GettyImages

Peacock has long been a struggling streaming service behind the big streamers like Netflix, Disney+ and Amazon Prime. As of December, peacock had a total of 28 million subscribers. Well that may seem like a large number, it places them 7th on the streaming service list. By comparison, ESPN plus has 26 million subscribers (as they're looking to enter a deal with NFL Network to boost their service). Netflix has over 247 million subscribers, Amazon Prime has over 200 million and Disney plus sits around 150 million subscribers.  Streamers are looking to capitalize on live sports as this seems to have a pay off.  Amazon Prime pays for NFL’s Thursday Night Games.  Amazon and Apple TV pay for exclusive MLB Baseball games during its regular season.  HBO’s Max service is partnering with B/R Sports to bring sports to the app (although this has been delayed). ESPN has plans to make ESPN+ a direct to consumer service and is looking into acquiring NFL’s NFL Network packages.

But one of the big questions is how did this gamble pay off for NBC and their peacock service? It seems to have had a positive effect overnight as the streaming service was at the top of most app stores in download and it's doubled its record search volume. Entrepreneur and investor Joe Pompliano as noted that NBC saw a record spike in search volume. His tweet on Sunday showed how Peacock’s search volume in Google is 2x their previous high all time and is sitting at the top of most app stores.  Peacock had long been home to exclusive rights to WWE pay-per-views and the WWE app, but had not seen this level of search volume during that run. It also shows how despite all of the complaining all week, including by the chefs on Sports City Chefs live NFL Free For All show, the NFL can do no wrong. Striking this deal with the NFL could possibly double their subscriber count and put them into the top five streaming services ahead of Paramount and Hulu.

Photo Credit: GettyImages

Despite the overnight success of the Peacock exclusive, it wasn't without us detractors. All week fans across the country complained about having to use the app service to watch the game, and how this is such a departure from having the game free on broadcast tv. Mike “Mad Dog” Russo even lamented on the Peacock deal during his weekly spot on First Take. There were viewers who complained about technical problems with the app during the broadcast. There were complaints of audio problems, streams glitch, hang ups during the action, or only getting a low-resolution version of the game. But those complaints seemed to be fewer than expected. However, on social media you are seeing more complaints about the constant cutaways and references to Swift from regular NFL fans.

Hate or love it, the NFL might have found something with this exclusive rights to an NFL game. While I don't feel they should make a habit of this, you can't deny the initial results. Peacock paid $110 million to bump their streaming service from the bottom of the list to the top. It was a calculated risk that might pay off in the long run for the struggling service. And again, the NFL prints money at an alarming rate. Nothing they do blows up in their face.