Control at the Point of Attack: How the Steelers Beat Cleveland at the Line of Scrimmage
Two 5-2 teams met for first place in the AFC North, and the surface case favored Cleveland. The Browns had won five games in the fourth quarter, beaten Pittsburgh 27-24 on a 56-yard field goal on Oct. 1, and led the league in tackles for loss. Watson also led the league in passer rating in the final two minutes of each half, the stretch where Cleveland had made its comebacks. Pittsburgh had one rushing touchdown all season and was missing Michael Pittman Jr., Roman Wilson and Ben Skowronek.
The Reality
Pittsburgh outgained Cleveland 361 to 319, ran for 200 yards, and sacked Deshaun Watson eight times. Cleveland’s 285 net passing yards were 324 gross minus 39 lost to sacks, and they produced no touchdowns. The win put Pittsburgh at 6-2 and alone atop the division. It also extended the Steelers’ home streak over Cleveland to 23 games, tying the NFL record against one opponent.
Category | Steelers | Browns |
Total yards | 361 | 319 |
Net passing yards | 161 | 285 |
Rushing yards | 200 | 34 |
Rushing touchdowns | 3 | 0 |
First-quarter yards | 135 | -1 |
Sacks taken | 1+ | 8 |
Turnovers | 1 | 2 |
The Offensive Line and the Running Game
Jaylen Warren tied his career high with 143 yards on 17 carries (8.4 per carry) on his 28th birthday. He had 102 yards at halftime, and his 51-yard run on third-and-13 set up a field goal. Rico Dowdle added 56 yards and a 9-yard touchdown. In 2025 Pittsburgh ranked 26th in rushing at about 103 yards per game, and in Week 4 it ran for 92. Sunday’s total came against a defense that led the league in tackles for loss, and the Steelers’ three rushing touchdowns were two more than they had scored on the ground all season before this game.
Pass protection held too. Rodgers’ 172 gross passing yards became 161 net, an improvement for a line that had allowed 22 sacks through seven games. The sources confirmed Troy Fautanu at left tackle, but not the full starting five.
Ball carrier | Carries | Yards | Avg | Notes |
Jaylen Warren | 17 | 143 | 8.4 | 1 TD; long 51 |
Rico Dowdle | 15 | 56 | 3.7 | 1 TD; long 15 |
Pat Freiermuth | 1 | n/a | n/a | 1-yd TD |
Steelers total | n/a | 200 | n/a | 3 TD |
Quinshon Judkins (CLE) | 11 | 25 | 2.3 | No long run |
Browns total | n/a | 34 | n/a | 0 TD |
The Passing Game
Aaron Rodgers was efficient rather than prolific: 13 of 25 for 172 yards, no touchdowns, and one interception that deflected off DK Metcalf’s hands to Denzel Ward. Three plays produced 110 of those yards: a 24-yard and a 58-yard catch by Darnell Washington, and a 28-yard catch by Pat Freiermuth. Washington finished with three catches for a career-high 94 yards, Freiermuth had two for 35, and no other receiver topped 35. Rodgers was 9 of 16 for 95 yards at halftime and 4 of 9 for 77 after it, then gave way to Mason Rudolph once the game was decided.
That tight-end production fits Brian Angelichio’s design, but it also means concentration risk. The wide receiver room was short-handed, and the plan will need to cover more of the field when those players return.
The 44-Second Drive
Cleveland’s 49-yard field goal with 45 seconds left cut the lead to 13-6. Pittsburgh had no timeouts. In 44 seconds the Steelers went 69 yards in six plays: a 23-yard Warren run, a 28-yard catch by Freiermuth, and a 15-yard catch by Germie Bernard to the goal line. McCarthy passed on a short field goal with five seconds left, Rodgers pushed to stay on the field, and Freiermuth scored from a yard out with one second remaining. The 20-6 halftime lead was never seriously threatened, and Warren’s 1-yard touchdown after Washington’s 58-yard catch made it 27-6 early in the third quarter.
Earlier comparisons in this series flagged clock management as a McCarthy weakness. This sequence is a counterexample worth logging, though one decision does not erase a pattern.
Time | Team | Scoring play | Score (CLE-PIT) |
Q1 7:57 | PIT | Dowdle 9-yd run | 0-7 |
Q2 14:05 | PIT | Boswell 20-yd FG | 0-10 |
Q2 8:43 | CLE | Szmyt 32-yd FG | 3-10 |
Q2 3:27 | PIT | Boswell 37-yd FG | 3-13 |
Q2 0:45 | CLE | Szmyt 49-yd FG | 6-13 |
Q2 0:01 | PIT | Freiermuth 1-yd run | 6-20 |
Q3 9:39 | PIT | Warren 1-yd run | 6-27 |
The Defensive Line
Pittsburgh’s eight sacks tied the most by any team in a game this season and were its most since a nine-sack game against the Browns in 2021. Cleveland had allowed 25 sacks through seven games, the most in the league, so this was roughly a third of that total in one afternoon. The Steelers sacked Watson on each of Cleveland’s first three drives and added seven tackles for loss.
Player | Sacks | Other impact |
T.J. Watt | 2 | Batted pass; 20.5 career sacks vs. Cleveland, an NFL record |
Patrick Queen | 1.5 | Team-high 12 tackles, forced fumble |
Cameron Heyward | 1.5 | Batted pass; third-and-1 stop of Judkins |
Nick Herbig | 1 | Edge pressure |
Kevin Jobity Jr. | 1 | First career sack; undrafted rookie |
Keeanu Benton | 0.5 | Fumble recovery |
Alex Highsmith | 0.5 | Early-drive sack |
Queen’s day matters because earlier analysis in this series documented his coverage struggles. One strong game is a positive data point, not a reversal.
Run Defense and Takeaways
Cleveland ran for 34 yards. Judkins had 25 on 11 carries. With 18 allowed to the Saints a week earlier, the last two games total 52 rushing yards.
Two takeaways. The Browns fumbled on their first two drives and Pittsburgh recovered both. Turnovers were the flagged weakness in Patrick Graham’s resume, but two in one game is a small sample.
Cleveland scored on two of 12 possessions, both field goals. A 12-play fourth-quarter drive reached the 5-yard line and ended on downs.
No second-half touchdown allowed since Week 3. The defense has shut out opponents after halftime two games in a row.
Not spotless. Watson passed for 324 yards, Harold Fannin Jr. caught 10 passes for 154, and Jaquan Brisker drew a roughing-the-passer penalty on the opening drive.
Special Teams
Chris Boswell made field goals of 20 and 37 yards and all three extra points, with one miss. Andre Szmyt made field goals of 32 and 49 for Cleveland. Safety Robert Spears-Jennings tackled the opening kickoff return after 26 yards. Skowronek, the punt-coverage specialist, was inactive with a calf injury. Punting, return and coverage data were not published in the sources reviewed, so this is the thinnest part of the analysis.
Week 4 Versus Week 8
Category | Week 4 (CLE 27-24) | Week 8 (PIT 27-6) |
Steelers rushing | 92 yds, 0 TD | 200 yds, 3 TD |
Browns rushing | 112 yds, 2 TD | 34 yds, 0 TD |
Steelers sacks recorded | 2 | 8 |
Steelers sacks taken | 5 | 1+ |
Steelers passing | 22/40, 269 yds, 3 TD, 2 INT | 13/25, 172 yds, 0 TD, 1 INT |
Bottom Line On the Steelers' Victory vs Browns
Pittsburgh won at the line of scrimmage on both sides of the ball, and the rest of the numbers followed. Three points matter going forward:
The formula is repeatable only if the lines hold. The win came from blocking and pass-rush advantages, not from Rodgers’ arm, so it depends on a healthy offensive line and a front that keeps producing negative plays.
The backfield is a strength. Warren supplied efficiency and big plays, and Dowdle supplied volume and short-yardage work. Both were organizational investments, and both paid off in the same game.
The passing game is the open question. The tight ends carried the yardage while three receivers were out, and the offense still has to prove it can stretch the field.
Next comes the bye week, then a trip to Cincinnati on Nov. 15 per the posted schedule.
Whether you're celebrating another dominant defensive showcase or getting ready for the next AFC North showdown, gear up with the latest official Pittsburgh Steelers apparel. From authentic sideline hoodies and hats to custom jerseys and cold-weather tailgating essentials, grab your official Black & Gold gear today at Fanatics. Every purchase through the link directly supports our coverage and independent reporting here at The Executive’s View.
Comments